Issue 2 - Ostara 2005
The Real Middle Earth by Brian Bates
reviewed by Robert Rehling


 

The author Brian Bates is a psychologist and a Professor at the University of Brighton in the UK. He specializes in the use of deep imagination in tribal cultures, the performing arts, and business, and he also directs a research programme and teaches a course in Shamanic Consciousness.

Most readers will be aware that the Middle Earth is the setting of Tolkien’s epic fantasy The Lord of the Rings and his earlier novel The Hobbit.  What they may not know that the term “Middle Earth” is an Old English or Anglo-Saxon term for the magical world in which these people and their ancestors lived.  Bates uses the term Real Middle Earth to refer to the culture that existed in north-west Europe and Scandinavia from about 0 to 1000 CE.  In this book he concentrates on ancient England but also refers to sources dealing with Scandinavia and mainland Europe.  He discusses how these people lived, their customs and beliefs, and especially their magic, and how these inspired Tolkien “to write Lord of the Rings as an attempt to invent a legendary story which captured this essence of ancient England”. 

The real Middle Earth is so named because in the Anglo-Saxon cosmology it was seen as existing between the Upper World of the Gods and the Lower World inhabited by the Dwarves.   Not only the name Middle Earth, but also many of the exotic creatures – including Dwarves, Orcs, Ents, Elves, and Dragons in the fantasy have been borrowed from ancient English mythology and folklore.  The character Gandalf has a close resemblance to the God Odin in his aspect of being an archetype for the wizards of the historical Middle Earth.  The fact that magic played an important part in the historical Middle Earth is indicated by the large number of words for different forms magic, divination, and witchcraft in the Anglo-Saxon language.

The author uses primary sources where possible, but when these are not available, he looks at alternative sources, such as laws and prohibitions designed to stamp out magical practices, documentation of rituals and healing techniques practiced by Christian priests, but which had their origin in pre-Christian times, and evidence from later Shamanistic cultures in other parts of the world.  For example there is no direct evidence of how wizards were initiated into their craft during the Middle Earth era, so Bates interpolates by examining a “Spider Spell” in the Anglo-Saxon Lacnunga manuscript, and combines this with what is known about the beliefs and practices of the Middle Earth era, to conclude that this was a Christianized account of an initiation rite for a wizard. 

This book would be of interest not only to fans of Tolkien’s fiction, but also anyone interested in the mythology and magical practices of old England and Western Europe.